Jon kicks off the festivities with a preamble drawn from his experience of reading my work.
We here at the Puppy of the Month Book Club have a knack for picking the first book of a series. We've done it with The Swan Knight's Son, The Chronicles of Amber, catskinner's book, and Nethereal. It's high time we revisited at least one of those universes, and none of them are as deserving as Brian [Niemeier's0 It was the very first Puppy of the Month, and it only took ten months to get to the sequel.
That's really too long.
Not just because it's too good of a series to languish that long, but because this is a challenging series to read. Frankly, Nethereal kicked my butt. Brian's writing is deceptively dense and is thoroughly riddled with multiple references and layers of meaning that completely escaped my typically shallow reading. It wasn't until Frisky and Nate [joined] in the conversation and started pulling on threads that I realized how knotted were the stitches that made up the Nethereal sweater. They introduced me to whole new dimensions in reading, and pushed me to approach the Book Club - and my other writing - with considerably more intellectual rigor, and to devote more time and thought to my own posts both here, at my blog, and over at Castalia House.Jon and his colleagues really do deserve a round of applause. I'm honored that they find my writing worthy of their considerable analytical skills. Based on their previous Puppy of the Month book reviews, it's safe to say we're in for a treat.
Frankly, I'm always a bit taken aback when readers say that the Soul Cycle is unusually dense in content and complex in terms of plot. It's all perfectly straightforward to me.
Then again, I'm the author, and I read everything in the exacting, contemplative way that Jon found most effective for reading Nethereal. I suspect that it stems from a mild, undiagnosed learning disorder that explains why I a) have an extremely slow reading speed and b) practically memorize almost everything I read.
Anyway, I think that Jon will find the going easier with Souldancer. The first book got most of the setup out of the way, letting SD's story hit the ground running. It will certainly be interesting to find out what the Puppy of the Month reviewers think.
Jon continues with a brief review and some speculation on Souldancer's prologue. I won't confirm or deny his conjectures, except to say that Almeth's pilgrimage to Kairos has more pertinent and far-reaching effects for SD and the entire Soul Cycle than he expects.
For those who missed the Puppy of the Month Book Club's epic, multi-part review of Nethereal, you can catch up here. Note that PotM reviews are intended as read-along exercises, so if you haven't read Nethereal or Souldancer, it is highly recommended that you remedy the situation before diving in.